What If Citizens Had to Vote on Every Law?
Society

What If Citizens Had to Vote on Every Law?

• 7 min read

The idea is simple. No parliament. No congress. No elected representatives making decisions on your behalf. Every law, regulation, and policy change goes directly to the people. You vote on it. All of it.

This sounds like democracy perfected. It is, in fact, democracy's nervous breakdown.

The volume problem

In the 2023-24 parliamentary session, the UK Parliament passed 38 Acts. That sounds manageable. Thirty-eight votes a year. You could do that over lunch.

But Acts are the visible tip. Beneath them sit statutory instruments: secondary legislation that implements the detail. The UK passes roughly 3,000 statutory instruments per year. These cover everything from the exact permitted level of cadmium in children's toys to the specific documentation required to import live crustaceans from Norway.

Three thousand votes a year is about eight per day, every day, weekends included. Each one requires reading the proposal, understanding the context, and making a decision. The average statutory instrument runs to 15-20 pages of legal text.

Your daily homework is now 120 to 160 pages of legislation.

Who actually votes?

Everyone can. Almost nobody does. Not for all of it.

Voter turnout in UK general elections hovers around 67%. That's once every four or five years, for one choice. Ask people to vote eight times a day, every day, and participation collapses. Within a month, the engaged fraction drops to the single digits.

Switzerland, the closest real-world example, holds federal referendums about four times a year with three to four questions each. Turnout averages 45%. And Swiss citizens regularly report feeling overwhelmed by the frequency. Scale that by a factor of two hundred and the system doesn't produce engaged citizens. It produces exhausted ones.

Enormous stack of legislative documents on a desk with a voting ballot on top

The people who do vote on everything are the people with time, strong opinions, and specific interests. Retirees. Activists. Lobbyists. Industry groups whose profits depend on the cadmium limits in children's toys. The voice of the general public, the whole point of direct democracy, gets drowned out by the people who care most about each individual issue.

This is worse than representative democracy, not better. At least MPs have staff to read the statutory instruments.

The competence gap

Some legislation is genuinely simple. Should the speed limit on residential roads be 20 mph? You can form a reasonable opinion on that without specialist knowledge. You drive on those roads. You live on those roads. Your experience is directly relevant.

Now consider the Financial Services and Markets Act 2023. It's 347 pages long. It restructures banking regulation post-Brexit, adjusts capital requirements for insurers, creates a new regime for crypto-asset promotion, and reforms the central counterparty resolution framework.

I understand about 40% of that sentence, and I've read the summary.

Direct democracy on complex legislation means voters choose between: reading and understanding the bill (impossible for most without specialist training), relying on someone else's summary (which is just representative democracy with extra steps), or guessing. Most people guess. They vote on vibes, on the title of the bill, on whether they trust the person recommending it.

A bill called the "Protecting Children Online Act" passes unanimously regardless of what's in it. Nobody votes against protecting children. The actual text could mandate installing government surveillance software on every phone in the country and it'd still pass, because who has time to read 200 pages when there are seven more votes before dinner?

The manipulation economy

In representative democracy, lobbyists need to persuade a few hundred politicians. Expensive, but contained. In direct democracy at this scale, they need to persuade millions of voters, and those voters are tired, distracted, and voting on instinct.

This is easier than it sounds.

You don't need to explain the nuance of a pharmaceutical regulation bill. You need a 30-second video that says "Big Pharma wants to raise your medicine prices. Vote NO on Proposal 1,847." Whether that's true is irrelevant. The voter has six more proposals to get through before the deadline.

Phone screen showing an overwhelming list of pending legislative votes

Social media becomes the de facto legislature. Whoever controls the narrative on Twitter, TikTok, and YouTube controls the vote. Algorithms that already optimise for outrage now optimise for legislative outcomes. Every vote is a content opportunity. Every proposal is a campaign.

Within a year, most people would subscribe to a "voting guide" service. A trusted source that tells them how to vote on each proposal. Some would follow a political party's recommendations. Others a newspaper's. Others an influencer's. The system designed to give power directly to citizens has recreated political parties, just without any of the institutional checks.

The speed problem

Legislation sometimes needs to happen fast. Emergency powers during a pandemic. Sanctions against an invading country. Responses to financial crises that move in hours.

A national vote, even a digital one, needs a minimum deliberation period to be legitimate. You can't put emergency legislation to 67 million people and expect an informed result in two hours. But the crisis won't wait for the vote to close.

So you build in exceptions. Emergency powers that bypass the voting requirement. A committee, perhaps, authorised to act without public approval in urgent situations. But who decides what's urgent? The committee does. And suddenly you've reinvented government. An unelected body with the power to bypass democratic process whenever they determine the situation warrants it.

Every authoritarian regime in history started with emergency powers. The mechanism that makes direct democracy workable in a crisis is the same mechanism that can be used to permanently override it.

The things that work

It's not all grim. Some categories of legislation genuinely benefit from direct public input.

Planning decisions. Should this green belt land be developed? The people who live near it have a direct, legitimate stake. Local referendums on planning already exist in some form, and they work tolerably well when the question is concrete and the affected population is small.

Moral questions. Abortion, euthanasia, drug legalisation, marriage equality. These are values decisions where specialist expertise matters less than public consensus. Ireland's 2018 abortion referendum showed that a population can engage seriously with a complex moral question when given time, information, and a clear binary choice.

Constitutional changes. Whether to adopt proportional representation, whether to abolish the monarchy, whether to leave a supranational body. Big structural questions that affect everyone deserve everyone's input.

The pattern is clear. Direct democracy works for big, infrequent, values-driven decisions with clear options. It fails for high-volume, technical, urgent, or specialised legislation. Which is most of it.

What would actually happen

You'd get a two-tier system within six months. The big symbolic votes (taxes, healthcare, defence spending) would draw 60-70% participation and genuine public deliberation. The other 2,950 annual decisions would be voted on by 3% of the population, dominated by interest groups, guided by algorithm-driven voting apps, and passed or rejected with less scrutiny than the average Amazon purchase.

The result is a government that looks democratic on the surface and is captured by organised interests underneath. Representative democracy has the same problem, of course. But at least with MPs, you can vote the bastards out.